Eren's Unstoppable Rumbling: What if Gabi Never Pulled the Trigger?

11 Jul 2024
us
Emil

Imagine a world shrouded in dust and despair. The earth trembles, not from a natural disaster, but from the colossal march of colossal beings. This isn't a hypothetical scenario; it's the potential outcome had Gabi Braun's bullet not found its mark, leaving Eren Yeager's Founding Titan unimpeded in his devastating Rumbling.

The pivotal moment where Gabi intercepts Eren mid-transformation is arguably the climax of Attack on Titan. What if that shot missed? What if Eren’s connection to the Founding Titan’s power remained unbroken? The repercussions are staggering, painting a picture of global annihilation on an unimaginable scale.

Had Gabi's shot gone astray, the Rumbling, Eren's apocalyptic plan to flatten the world beyond Paradis Island, would have continued unchecked. The Wall Titans, colossal humanoid weapons of mass destruction, would have relentlessly marched across the globe, crushing civilizations and obliterating all life in their path. This alternate timeline presents a chilling scenario where humanity outside Paradis is utterly extinguished.

Understanding the implications of an uninterrupted Rumbling requires understanding the power of the Founding Titan. Inherited from Ymir Fritz, the Founding Titan holds the ability to control all other Titans and manipulate the memories of Eldians. Eren, fueled by his desire to protect Paradis, harnesses this immense power to enact his brutal plan, believing it's the only way to secure his people's future. Without Gabi's intervention, this power remains entirely in his hands, a terrifying prospect for the rest of the world.

The debate surrounding Eren's actions and motivations is complex. Some argue he was driven to extremes by the constant threat of annihilation faced by Paradis. Others condemn his choice, viewing the Rumbling as a horrific act of genocide. But had Gabi missed, that debate would be rendered moot. The world beyond Paradis would cease to exist, leaving only the chilling silence of a planet reshaped by colossal destruction.

The origin of the Founding Titan stems back to Ymir Fritz and her pact with a mysterious entity. This power, passed down through generations, eventually landed in Eren's possession. Its significance lies in its absolute control over Eldians and Titans, making it a weapon of immense potential and devastating consequence.

Eren’s potential complete Rumbling raises profound moral questions. Did he have the right to decide the fate of the entire world? Was genocide a justifiable act of self-preservation? These questions are further amplified in a scenario where the Rumbling reaches its horrific conclusion.

One hypothetical benefit (from Eren's perspective) of a completed Rumbling would be the absolute security of Paradis Island. Free from external threats, the Eldians could rebuild and create a new society. However, this “benefit” comes at the cost of immeasurable human suffering and global annihilation.

Another hypothetical "benefit" is the potential for a unified Eldian society. With the threat of external conflict removed, the internal divisions within Paradis could potentially heal. This, however, is a highly speculative outcome given the deep-seated tensions within Paradisian society.

A final (and again, highly problematic) "benefit" is the eradication of the Titan curse. With the world's population decimated, the need for Titans as weapons of war would become obsolete. This, however, is a pyrrhic victory achieved through global genocide.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Eren's Completed Rumbling

Advantages (from Eren's perspective)	Disadvantages
Absolute security for Paradis Island	Global annihilation and immeasurable human suffering
Potential for a unified Eldian society	Moral condemnation as an act of genocide
Eradication of the Titan curse	Destruction of global culture and history

Frequently Asked Questions about a Completed Rumbling:

1. Could anyone have stopped Eren?: Potentially, if someone had access to the Founding Titan's power and the will to oppose him.

2. What would be the long-term environmental impact?: Catastrophic and irreversible damage to ecosystems and the planet's climate.

3. Would Paradis Island survive the aftermath?: Likely, but the long-term sustainability of their isolated society is questionable.

4. Could the Eldians rebuild the world?: Highly unlikely, given the scale of destruction.

5. Would Eren have any regrets?: This is a matter of intense debate among fans.

6. Could the Rumbling have been prevented?: Potentially, through diplomatic solutions and addressing the root causes of the conflict.

7. What would the world look like after the Rumbling?: A desolate wasteland.

8. Is there any justification for Eren's actions?: A complex moral question with no easy answers.

In conclusion, the scenario where Gabi misses her shot on Eren paints a grim picture of a world utterly devastated by the Rumbling. While the motivations behind Eren's actions are complex and debated, the consequences of an unchecked Founding Titan are undeniable. The potential "benefits" of a completed Rumbling are dwarfed by the horrific cost of global genocide. This alternate timeline serves as a chilling reminder of the delicate balance of power and the devastating consequences of unchecked ambition. It compels us to consider the complexities of morality, the dangers of extremism, and the importance of seeking peaceful solutions to conflict. The thought experiment of Gabi's missed shot underscores the immense responsibility that comes with wielding power, particularly power as absolute as that of the Founding Titan. It leaves us with a lingering question: at what cost is security achieved, and is that cost ever truly worth it?